I grew up in Cleveland, OH and I am Polish so baked goods were a huge part of my childhood. It was a rare occurrence when I didn't visit my grandmother's house and spend half the time in the kitchen baking and cooking. Palachinkas, homemade Pierogi's and homemade baked bread were my favorite things to make with my grandmother and sisters. Homemade is always better in my eyes because it's made with love and brings a lifetime of memories with it. I lived near Colozza's Bakery and they made the most delicious Cassata cake that became a family favorite. We always bought one for birthdays, graduations and shoot my own sister had a similar cake baked for her very own wedding. Why, because it's DELICIOUS!!
So when my mother's birthday grew nearer my first year out here, I made it a goal to make a cassata cake for her. For the last two years, I have "failed." The cake was good but it didn't have that same taste. Well this year, I am proud to report I have come close to perfect! My mom said the taste was there, and she is a cassata cake snob so that approval was all I needed.
First, you make two 8 inch round cakes (I'd stick with a white cake or french vanilla recipe).
Then you make a delicious pastry cream for the filling.
Cut some strawberries
And then assemble, frost and decorate!!!
* Best purchase I have made was a cake leveler so you can get that nice flat top!
So you can make this cake two different ways.
1.) I like more filling then cake, so I cut each round cake into two separate pieces and then use a leveler to make them flat and stack them that way, with the filling in between each layer. I'm not much of a cake person so the more filling the better. The cake won't keep as long that way because it can get soggy quicker.
2.) Or you can just level each cake so they are flat and a bit shorter then when it came out of the oven and end up having two cakes with one layer of filling in between.
Both ways are delicious, the second will keep longer, but honestly, this cake isn't going to last long in the fridge anyways so do whatever you'll like most. If you love cake, make the second version, if you like more filling and less heaviness of the cake use the first version!
For the Cake:
1 Box of White Cake/French Vanilla Cake - I used French Vanilla by Betty Crocker
1 Cup Flour
1 Cup Sugar
3/4 Tsp Salt
4 Egg Whites (Save two of the yolks for the pastry cream)
1 1/3 cups water
2 Tbsp Vegetable Oil
1 Cup Sour Cream
1 Tsp Vanilla (Clear or if you don't have clear just regular)
1 Tsp Almond Extract
- Preheat oven according to your package of cake directions.
- Spray and flour two 8 inch round cake pans (Make sure they are the same size, mine were a bit off which I didn't realize until I went to assemble, it won't make much of a different but it will be prettier).
- Mix dry ingredients, then add all the wet ingredients and stir until incorporated
- Pour evenly into two pans
- Bake according to the instructions on the box
* When cakes are done, cool the pans on a rack for 5 minutes. Then take two pieces of long plastic wrap creating a t-shape over one cake and then flip over to completely cover the warm cake. Then repeat with the other cake. It's important to do this step 5 minutes after coming out of the oven, because wrapping them up will retain all that moisture and prevent them from becoming dry. Set to cool, then pop them in the freezer until read to use.
For the Pastry Cream: You'll have more cream then you need if you only do one layer, but then you can use it on something else, it's great as a filling for cakes or other pastries
2 Cups of milk (I used 1% milk)
1/4 Cup Sugar
2 Egg Yolks
1 Egg
1/4 Cup Corn Starch
1/3 Cup Sugar
2 Tbsp Butter
1/2 Tsp Vanilla
3 Snack Pack Vanilla Pudding Cups
- In a medium saucepan, combine milk and the 1/4 cup sugar and bring to a boil
- In a medium bowl, whisk yolks and egg
- Mix Corn Starch and 1/3 cup sugar and then add to egg mixture and stir until smooth
- When milk reaches boiling, remove from stove and slowly and consistently add to egg mixture while stirring consistently so you don't cook the eggs
- Add entire mixture back to pan and bring to boil. Stir constantly so it doesn't burn to bottom. It will thicken, when it gets to a boil and thickens, remove from heat
- Add butter and vanilla and stir until butter has melted
- Pour in container and cover with plastic wrap so it doesn't get a film on the top and pop into your fridge until it cools
- When it finishes cooling, add snack packs and stir it in until it's incorporated
For Strawberries:
I cut almost 2 packs of strawberries into thin slices. I sprinkled some sugar on them.
* If only using 1 layer of filling, cut in half *
For the Whipped Cream Topping:
Use 1 cup of Whipping cream, add a packet of Whip Cream Stabilizer so it keeps the frosting together. Whip on high speed until it starts to thicken, then add a little vanilla and some powder sugar to your taste. Beat until soft peaks form. Make the whipped topping when you are done assembling the cake.
To Assemble Cake:
- Take cakes out of freezer and defrost just a bit but keep a little frozen when cutting, it will be easier to assemble, cut and frost
- Put one cake on a plate or buy a cheap cardboard circle from your local bakery store. Cut one cake in half and set the top half aside. Use a cake leveler to make the top flat. Use spatula to spread pastry cream over top and add strawberries in a smooth layer.
* If you want the cake to absorb a little of the red liquid from the strawberries, put the strawberries on first then the cream, adds a little bit of fun, I didn't this time around. *
- Then level the top half of the first cake and then add on top of the filling layer.
* Don't try to level on cake, you'll want to do it on flat solid surface otherwise the cake could break or slide around on the top of the cake *
- Put more filling on top of the second layer of cake and then repeat with the other cake
- Frost cake when final layer of cake is on top. To make that nice wavy design, I just took the back of a spoon and pressed it into the whipped cream once it was on the cake and flip up and out a bit. It made it kind of fun
- Then decorate however you want. I used pearl sprinkles because I think they are pretty and cute!!
Put in fridge and eat cold, it tastes better!
Look at all those pretty layers, eat up! Happy Birthday Mommy!!